Skip to content

Who is liable for a slip and fall on a commercial lot in New Jersey, and why service records matter

Since 1968|All of South Jersey|Commercial and municipal|Seasonal and per-push contracts|Lines answered 24/7 in storms
SBO Snow blog|Liability

Who is liable for a slip and fall on a commercial lot in New Jersey, and why service records matter

November 2026

This is not legal advice; talk to your attorney or your insurance carrier about your own property. It is a plain description of how slip-and-fall claims tend to go in New Jersey, written by people who get asked for the service record after every one of them.

The owner’s duty

In New Jersey, a commercial property owner is expected to take reasonable steps to keep lots, walkways and entrances safe for the people who use them, including clearing snow and ice within a reasonable time after a storm. Many municipalities add a specific sidewalk ordinance on top of that, with a clearing window of 12 to 24 hours and fines for missing it. “Reasonable” is decided after the fact, by someone looking at what you did and when.

Where the contractor fits

Hiring a snow contractor does not move the duty off the owner, but it changes what “reasonable” looks like. A property with a signed contract, a stated trigger depth, a re-plow interval and a salting plan has already done the planning a court expects. A property with a handshake deal and no record of when anyone showed up has not.

Why the service record is the whole case

Most claims come down to one question: was the lot in a reasonable condition at the time the person fell? If your contractor can produce a log showing the lot was plowed at 4:10 AM, salted at 4:40 AM and checked again at 6:15 AM, and the fall happened at 7:30 AM, you have a defense. If the only evidence is the claimant’s description of the ice, you do not.

That is why every SBO visit is logged with the time, the service performed and the conditions, kept for the season and available to you and your carrier on request. It is also why we log refreeze checks on nights when nothing was plowed: those are the nights the claims come from.

Things that weaken a defense

  • Gaps between the end of the storm and the first visit with no explanation
  • No salting after a melt-and-refreeze day
  • Sidewalks left to the tenant’s staff with no record of when they were done
  • Snow stacked where it melts across a walkway and refreezes
  • A contract that says “as needed” with nobody deciding what that means

Things that help

  • A written contract with trigger depth, interval and salting terms
  • Pre-treatment before ice events
  • Refreeze checks on cold nights after a melt
  • A time-stamped log for every visit, including salt-only visits
  • A certificate of insurance from the contractor on file before the season

Ask for the record before you need it

If your current contractor cannot show you last winter’s service log for your property, you do not have one. Ask now, in November, not in a deposition in June.

Questions about your property?
856-593-4221

Call John at 856-593-4221 or request a site walk. Commercial and municipal properties only, across South Jersey.

Read next: Contracts and pricing · Commercial snow plowing · FAQ

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *